| Platinum Dragon Totem | Original EverQuest (Classic) | CLASSIC Named 29 Pool 5 |
| Platinum Symbol | The Scars of Velious | VELIOUS Raid 60 Pool 4 |
| Platinum Tear | The Scars of Velious | VELIOUS Raid 66 Pool 2 |
| Pod of Seawater | The Ruins of Kunark | KUNARK Raid 55 Pool 1 |
| Poison Soaked Tunic | The Scars of Velious | VELIOUS Raid 66 Pool 3 |
| Poison Symbol | The Scars of Velious | VELIOUS Raid 60 Pool 4 |
| Poison Tear | The Scars of Velious | VELIOUS Raid 66 Pool 2 |
| Poisoned Mantle | The Ruins of Kunark | KUNARK Raid 65 Pool 1 |
| Polished Bone Hoop | Original EverQuest (Classic) | CLASSIC Named 25 Pool 4 |
| Polished Brass Key | Original EverQuest (Classic) | CLASSIC Named 23 Pool 4 |
| Polished Granite Tomahawk | Original EverQuest (Classic) | CLASSIC Named 20 Pool 3 |
| Pouch of Ghoul Ash | Original EverQuest (Classic) | CLASSIC Named 22 Pool 4 |
| Power of Fire | Original EverQuest (Classic) | CLASSIC Named 35 Pool 6 |
| Prismatic Bauble of Endless Jests | The Scars of Velious | VELIOUS Raid 70 Pool NA |
| Prismatic Dragon Scale | The Scars of Velious | VELIOUS Raid 69–70 Pool 2 |
| Prismatic Shield | Original EverQuest (Classic) | CLASSIC Raid 56 Pool 2 |
| Pugius | Original EverQuest (Classic) | CLASSIC Named 19 Pool 3 |
| Pulsating Brood Clutch | Original EverQuest (Classic) | CLASSIC Named 10 Pool 1 |
| Pulsing Green Stone | The Ruins of Kunark | KUNARK Raid 55 Pool 1 |
| Rakusha Cloak | Original EverQuest (Classic) | CLASSIC Raid 56 Pool 2 |
| Rat Bone Powder | Original EverQuest (Classic) | CLASSIC Named 12 Pool 2 |
| Ravenscale Armguards | Original EverQuest (Classic) | CLASSIC Named 34 Pool 6 |
| Ravenscale Boots | Original EverQuest (Classic) | CLASSIC Named 36 Pool 7 |
| Ravenscale Bracer | Original EverQuest (Classic) | CLASSIC Named 28 Pool 5 |
| Ravenscale Chestguard | Original EverQuest (Classic) | CLASSIC Named 38 Pool 7 |
| Ravenscale Coif | Original EverQuest (Classic) | CLASSIC Named 30 Pool 5 |
| Ravenscale Gloves | Original EverQuest (Classic) | CLASSIC Named 35 Pool 6 |
| Ravenscale Leggings | Original EverQuest (Classic) | CLASSIC Named 30 Pool 5 |
| Razor Fang of Xygoz | The Ruins of Kunark | KUNARK Raid 65 Pool 1 |
| Razor Sharp Short Sword | The Ruins of Kunark | KUNARK Raid 65 Pool 1 |
| Reaver | The Scars of Velious | VELIOUS Raid 59 Pool 3 |
| Red Resistance Stone | The Scars of Velious | VELIOUS Raid 70 Pool 2 |
| Red Wood Wand | Original EverQuest (Classic) | CLASSIC Named 20 Pool 3 |
| Reed Belt | Original EverQuest (Classic) | CLASSIC Named 30 Pool 5 |
| Reed Ring | Original EverQuest (Classic) | CLASSIC Named 22 Pool 4 |
| Rekeklo's War Sword | The Scars of Velious | VELIOUS Raid 66 Pool 3 |
| Ribcage Chest Armor | Original EverQuest (Classic) | CLASSIC Named 16 Pool 3 |
| Rime Encrusted Harness | The Scars of Velious | VELIOUS Raid 69 Pool 2 |
| Ring of Destruction | The Scars of Velious | VELIOUS Raid 70 Pool 1 |
| Ring of Goblin Lords | Original EverQuest (Classic) | CLASSIC Named 30 Pool 5 |
| Ring of Lightning | The Scars of Velious | VELIOUS Raid 70 Pool 1 |
| Ring of Relkententinar | The Scars of Velious | VELIOUS Raid 66 Pool 3 |
| Ring of the Frozen Flame | The Scars of Velious | VELIOUS Raid 65 Pool 3 |
| Ring of the Sky | The Scars of Velious | VELIOUS Raid 66 Pool 3 |
| Ring of Winter | The Scars of Velious | VELIOUS Raid 70 Pool 3 |
| Ring of Xorbb | Original EverQuest (Classic) | CLASSIC Named 25 Pool 4 |
| Riptide Spear | Original EverQuest (Classic) | CLASSIC Named 15 Pool 2 |
| Robe of Adversity | The Ruins of Kunark | KUNARK Raid 65 Pool 1 |
| Robe of Invocation (removed) | The Ruins of Kunark | KUNARK Raid 65 Pool 1 |
| Robe of Smothering | The Ruins of Kunark | KUNARK Raid 65 Pool 1 |
| Robe of the Azure Sky | The Ruins of Kunark | KUNARK Raid 70 Pool 1 |
| Robe of the Ishva | The Ruins of Kunark | KUNARK Raid 58 Pool 2 |
| Robe of the Kedge | Original EverQuest (Classic), The Ruins of Kunark | CLASSIC Raid 53 Pool NR, KUNARK Raid 55–58 Pool 2 |
| Robe of the Spring (removed) | The Ruins of Kunark | KUNARK Raid 65 Pool 1 |
| Rod of Health | Original EverQuest (Classic) | CLASSIC Named 47 Pool 9 |
| Rod of Infinite Thought | Original EverQuest (Classic) | CLASSIC Raid 56 Pool 2 |
| Rod of Malisement | Original EverQuest (Classic) | CLASSIC Raid 53 Pool NR |
| Rod of the Healers | The Scars of Velious | VELIOUS Raid 70 Pool NA |
| Rokyl's Channeling Crystal | Original EverQuest (Classic) | CLASSIC Named 51 Pool 10 |
| Royal Shai`din Insignia | The Ruins of Kunark | KUNARK Raid 68 Pool NA |
| Rubicite Boots | Original EverQuest (Classic) | CLASSIC Named 36 Pool 7 |
| Rubicite Breastplate | Original EverQuest (Classic) | CLASSIC Named 38 Pool 7 |
| Rubicite Gauntlets | Original EverQuest (Classic) | CLASSIC Named 35 Pool 6 |
| Rubicite Helm | Original EverQuest (Classic) | CLASSIC Named 30 Pool 5 |
| Ruby Symbol | The Scars of Velious | VELIOUS Raid 60 Pool 4 |
| Ruby Tear | The Scars of Velious | VELIOUS Raid 66 Pool 2 |
| Ruined Battleworn Morning Star | The Ruins of Kunark | KUNARK Raid 55 Pool 2 |
| Ruinous Blade of Annihilation | The Scars of Velious | VELIOUS Raid 75 Pool NA |
| Runebladed Sword of Night | The Ruins of Kunark | KUNARK Raid 58 Pool 2 |
| Runebranded Girdle | The Ruins of Kunark | KUNARK Raid 55–58 Pool 2 |
| Runed Bone Fork | Original EverQuest (Classic) | CLASSIC Named 17 Pool 3 |
| Runed Lava Pendant | Original EverQuest (Classic) | CLASSIC Named 35 Pool 6 |
| Runed Morning Star | The Ruins of Kunark | KUNARK Raid 55 Pool 2 |
| Runed Oak Bow | Original EverQuest (Classic) | CLASSIC Named 18 Pool 3 |
| Runed Symbol | The Scars of Velious | VELIOUS Raid 60 Pool 4 |
| Runed Tear | The Scars of Velious | VELIOUS Raid 66 Pool 2 |
| Runestone Maul | The Ruins of Kunark | KUNARK Raid 65 Pool 1 |
| Sacrifice | The Scars of Velious | VELIOUS Raid 70 Pool 1 |
| Salindrite Dagger | The Scars of Velious | VELIOUS Raid 70 Pool 2 |
| Sarnak Channeler's Staff | The Ruins of Kunark | KUNARK Raid 65 Pool 1 |
